False Models as Explanatory Engines
نویسندگان
چکیده
Many models in economics are very unrealistic. At the same time, economists put a lot of effort in making their models more realistic. I argue that in many cases, including the Modigliani-Miller irrelevance theorem investigated in this paper, the purpose of this process of concretization is explanatory. When evaluated in combination with their assumptions, a highly unrealistic model may well be true. The purpose of relaxing an unrealistic assumption, then, need not be to move from a false model to a true one. Instead, it may be providing an explanation of some phenomenon by invoking the factor that figures in the assumption. This idea is developed in terms of the contrastive account of explanation. It is argued that economists use highly unrealistic assumptions in order to determine a contrast that is worth explaining. The process of concretization also motivates new explanatory questions. A high degree of explanatory power, then, may well be due to a high number of unrealistic assumptions. Thus, highly unrealistic models can be powerful explanatory engines.
منابع مشابه
Modeling Cognition: How Fiction Relates to Fact
The increasing use of computational modeling and simulation methods offers interesting epistemic and theoretical challenges for the philosophy of science. One of the main questions discussed in the philosophical literature relates to the explanatory role of false, unrealistic and sometimes even fictional models. In this paper we argue that (i) some fictional models can offer explanations known ...
متن کاملUnmodeled observation error induces bias when inferring patterns and dynamics of species occurrence via aural detections.
The recent surge in the development and application of species occurrence models has been associated with an acknowledgment among ecologists that species are detected imperfectly due to observation error. Standard models now allow unbiased estimation of occupancy probability when false negative detections occur, but this is conditional on no false positive detections and sufficient incorporatio...
متن کاملHow scientific models can explain
Scientific models invariably involve some degree of idealization, abstraction, or fictionalization of their target system. Nonetheless, I argue that there are circumstances under which such false models can offer genuine scientific explanations. After reviewing three different proposals in the literature for how models can explain, I shall introduce a more general account of what I call model e...
متن کاملSelf - explanatory simulators : making computers partners in the modeling process
Digital computers have dramatically aided the application of mathematical models to problems of all kinds . For the most part computers have served as calculating engines, data . retrieval and sorting devices, and lately as a powerful medium for visualization . Rarely have computers been used to assist in the more conceptual stages of investigations, for example in formulating the models to be ...
متن کاملDetecting Spam Blogs: A Machine Learning Approach
Weblogs or blogs are an important new way to publish information, engage in discussions, and form communities on the Internet. The Blogosphere has unfortunately been infected by several varieties of spam-like content. Blog search engines, for example, are inundated by posts from splogs – false blogs with machine generated or hijacked content whose sole purpose is to host ads or raise the PageRa...
متن کامل